How about DNA Testing?

Starting point: definition of DNA
DNA stands for "deoxyribonucleic acid." It is inside of cells called chromosomes. It carries all the information about how a living thing will look and function. Genes are different sections of the DNA that carry each piece of information, such as color of eyes or how body parts work.
Loosely speaking, DNA was discovered in the late 1800s and further research revealed that DNA contains genes in the 1950s. There was a 1940s case involving Charlie Chaplain to exclude him as the father of a child, and they used blood type testing because it was clear that blood type was passed genetically.
DNA was used by law enforcement in the 1990s, and, apparently, DNA was part of the skepticism surrounding the OJ Simpson trial in 1995.
Today DNA is widely accepted in law enforcement as evidence. It is paid by tax payers through the DA's office and the applicable law enforcement organization, often outsourced to private labs.
Today DNA is not mandated for paternity. In fact, it's only considered helpful in a Louisiana case as "clear and convincing evidence," to establish a prima facie case.
Next step: defining a presumption and a prima facie case
Merriam Webster Dictionary defines "presumption" as "a legal inference as to the existence or truth of a fact not certainly known that is drawn from the known or proved existence of some other fact."
Black's Law Dictionary defines "presumption" as "an inference affirmative or disaffirmative of the truth or falsehood of any proposition or fact drawn by a process of probable reasoning in the absence of actual certainty of its truth or falsehood, or until such certainty can be ascertained."
Merriam Webster Dictionary defines "prima facie" as "legally sufficient to establish a fact or case unless disproved."
Black's Law Dictionary's entry on "prima" is " Lat. At first sight; on the first appearance; on the face of it... A litigating party is said to have a prima ie case when the evidence in his favor is sufficiently strong for his opponent to be called to answer it. A prima facie case, then , is one which is established by sufficient evidence, and can be overthrown only by rebutting evidence adduced on the other side."
As a lawyer, I have a new pet peeve: when lawyers and judges conflate "presumption" with "prima facie case." How does this apply to paternity?
The Louisiana paternity laws create a presumption that there is a father under only two circumstances: the husband of the mother is presumed to be the father of her child (La. C.C. Art. 185) and acknowledging paternity of an unmarried mother's child by authentic act (La. C.C. Art. 196). There are caveats surrounding both presumptions, however, such as if the biological father is not the husband of the mother and the acknowledgement can only be invoked on behalf of the child. These caveats require litigation to receive the legal benefits of them. Put another way, the only truly legally protected children, the only children born in this world who are 100% legally born with an iron-clad father are those born to the husband of their mother and said husband is also the DNA father.
Wait, the presumptions say nothing about DNA. Why would you bring up that the husband needs to be the DNA father? Yes! This is where the "prima facie case" is needed.
Louisiana offers La. C.C. Art. 197 for the child's action to establish paternity and La. C.C. Art. 198 for the father's action to establish paternity. I guess the "mother's action to establish paternity" is simply get married? (And accept all the awful financial repercussions that come with marriage when there is no prenuptial agreement signed?!) There is no mother's action to establish paternity, so, yes, I seriously think the only way the mother has control of the child's paternity, under her own name, in her own right, is to marry the child's father. Under all circumstances, she is the proper person to bring the C.C. Art. 197 action to establish paternity on behalf of the child.
These 197 and 198 actions are examples of a "prima facie case." A case requires evidence. An example of evidence is a DNA testing printout showing both the father's name and the child's name. Another example of evidence is a document that upholds the 196 presumption. The result of a 197 or 198 action is a "judgment of paternity," which legally is as good as being the husband of the mother, for paternity purposes.
Again, I am setting aside the issues of a disavowal, etc., as it regards a married man, or a cuckold. I am, however, very interested in the 196 signature that creates a presumption.
When is the right time to attach a presumption?
It is my assertion that a 196 presumption of paternity is only effective when the sheet of paper showing this authentic act is presented for its purpose.
Once the sheet of paper is presented to one entity, it does not establish paternity across the board. It must be presented to entity after entity, over and over, unless there is a judgment of paternity, which by contrast, is effective at all times to establish paternity on the date the Judge signs it.
COSTS OF DNA TESTING as a barrier for proper establishment of paternity.
Is there a stigma around DNA testing?
Why don’t married men do this? They’re in the best position financially to complete a DNA test.
How can the law mandate that health insurance cover a DNA test on all babies born in Louisiana?
If a DNA test cannot be performed at the time of baby’s birth because any reason (mom disagrees, dad won’t submit, dad is out of town, etc), then only the mom would be the parent. Until dad submits to a DNA test. WHY IS THIS NOT THE LAW?! I’m too young for this nonsense antiquated law we are dealing with right now. This is legit what makes the most scientific sense.
Reassurances that baby’s and dad’s DNA are not kept in any long term database.
State funded DNA if health insurance can’t help (I can’t even get an unmedicated birth/delivery paid for as in-network by my Louisiana health insurance, i have no expectation that DNA would be covered, even if it is provided by law)
I’d like to abolish La. R.S. 9:397.1. Compensation of expert witnesses and recovery of testing costs, and replace it with mandatory DNA for all babies funded by a state or private health insurance source. There’s no way there’s money for epidurals and pitocin and all that stuff but not money for DNA screens. And when we opt out of those things, we pay more anyway. This is a systemic issue, not an individual issue. In fact, it’s exactly the individual issue of creating different “classes” of children/fathers that I’m arguing against.
La. R.S. 9:397.1:
“A. The costs of the blood or tissue tests conducted by the expert witness appointed by the court shall be fixed at a reasonable amount. The costs shall be advanced by the party who requested that such tests be conducted. If the court orders the blood or tissue tests on its own motion, the petitioner shall advance the costs of the tests. In either case, the court shall tax the costs to the party against whom judgment is rendered. The compensation of each expert witness appointed by the court and called by a party shall be fixed at a reasonable amount. It shall be paid by the party against whom judgment is rendered, which shall be taxed as costs of court.
B. If the state, a political subdivision of the state, or the petitioner pays the initial costs of testing under this Part in a paternity action, the state, political subdivision, or petitioner may recover those costs from an individual only if he is found to be the father of the child in the action. If an income assignment order is issued, the reimbursement for the costs shall be ordered through the income assignment order. If an income assignment order has not been issued, the court shall determine the manner in which the reimbursement for the costs shall be made.”
This encourages mom and dad to rush to the court house to file their request for DNA. What in holy hell does “B” mean? Does it presume that the “petitioner” is the mother? If so, it requires/assumes mom to front the cost of DNA.




Comments